Table of contents

When debt payments are overdue, the creditor may assign a debt collector, which consequently affects your credit report. U.S. citizens hold a tremendous amount of debt, reaching $18.04 trillion in the fourth quarter of 2024. Collection accounts may stay on credit reports for up to seven years, and such debts rapidly affect your credit score. In short, it’s possible that paying off a collection account can enhance your credit score. However, it largely depends on credit scoring software. 

In this blog, we will take a look at whether paying collections helps your credit score. We will also understand some of the new credit scoring software that affects your credit report and the steps you can take to pay off collection accounts. 

Understanding Collection Accounts

A collection account is an entry on your credit report that indicates an unpaid debt in default. These accounts typically appear on credit reports and negatively impact your credit scores. Collection agents are proactive in recovering their debts, so regular checking of your credit report is unnecessary to determine if an account is in collections. 

Paying off your debts is a positive step that can alleviate pressure from debt collectors. Additionally, settling an account may have a favorable impact on your credit score.

How Do Collections Impact Your Credit Score?

Collections are part of the payment history, which is a critical factor in the FICO Score.  FICO® 10 T and VantageScore 4.0 calculations account for 35% of your payment history. The overall impact of collections on credit scores has shifted and depends on two factors: the nature of the debt and the version of the credit scoring model. 

Here are some of the criteria that impact collection on scores:

  • FICO® Scores 9 and 10 are the latest versions that disregard all paid collections and conservatively lower scores for unpaid medical bills, unlike other types of debt. 
  • FICO® 8 is the most common version, which does not make these distinctions and significantly lowers the score for any debt of $100 or more on your credit report, regardless of whether it is paid or unpaid. 
  • VantageScore 3.0 and 4.0 are the latest iterations of scoring software from the national credit bureaus’ joint score development venture. They disregard all paid collections and all medical collections, whether paid or unpaid. However, unpaid non-medical collection accounts can negatively impact your VantageScore credit score. 

Collection accounts and other derogatory marks can remain on your credit reports for up to seven years. However, whether these collection accounts are paid or unpaid can change their effects on credit scores. 

Will Paying Collections Help Credit Score?

Depending on the nature of your collection account and credit models, paying off a collection account can increase your credit score or have no effect.

  • Effectively paying off a collection account can enhance credit scores calculated using FICO® Score 9 and 10, along with VantageScore 3.0 and 4.0. However, such effects do not extend to older FICO scoring models. 
  • Paying off smaller debt amounts does not have a major effect on your credit score. These are also known as nuisance accounts and originally under $100. FICO 8 disregards such debts, and VantageScore 3.0 ignore collections under $250. 

Debts in collections may also include other interests and fees. So, regardless of whether it enhances your credit score, the smart way is to pay off collection accounts as early as possible. 

Strategies for Enhancing Your Credit Score After Collections 

The question of whether paying off a collection will or won’t enhance your credit scores largely depends on the latest credit scoring models. However, the following strategies are tried and tested that can improve your credit scores no matter the credit scoring software used:

1. On-time payments 

 The key to a strong credit score is reducing the chances of any negative entries in your report. You can achieve it with regular payments and by creating a budget that is best suited to autopayment tools. A consistent payment won’t affect your credit scores. 

2. Minimum Credit Card Debts

Low credit card debt is another great strategy for increasing credit scores. Most credit scoring models use the credit utilization ratio as a percentage that reflects your credit limits. A lower balance suggests a low utilization ratio, which can help you enhance your overall credit scores. 

3. Reducing Overdependence on Credits 

Each time you apply for a new credit, the lender will acquire details of your credit history. It results in hard inequities on your report, which can abruptly lower your credit scores temporarily. In most cases, inquiries are the least influential criteria that affect your credit score. However, it can still be a negative factor for lenders. 

Also read: Best Credit Repair Companies of 2025

3 Steps to Pay Off Debt in Collections

Improving your credit scores requires responsible credit usage over time, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) recommend undertaking the following steps when paying off your debts:

Step 1: Make Sure the Debt is Yours

The law requires debt collectors to provide specific information regarding the debt. Typically, this information should be delivered in writing within five days of contacting you. The CFPB also recommends utilizing the available data to verify the debt's origin and requesting that collectors provide additional details about the debt. 

Step 2: Strategize Repayment Plans

The next step is to evaluate your monthly budget and develop a realistic plan for settling collections. The CFPB warns against neglecting other bills to pay off collection debts, as this may lead to further financial harm in the future. Moreover, the CFPB indicates that using a debt settlement organization can be a risky strategy in such situations. 

Step 3: Negotiate with Debt Collectors

The final step is maintaining proactive communication with debt collectors and strategizing effective repayment or settlement plans. For the best outcomes, you can achieve this with the assistance of an attorney or credit counsellor. Once both parties reach an agreement, be sure to get it in writing. 

Devising a systematic approach may sound daunting, but it becomes easy with proper guidance. Shepherd Outsourcing Services can provide you with end-to-end expertise in developing a suitable roadmap that meets your financial goals and effortlessly managing collection accounts.  

Benefits of Paid Collection Accounts 

In the second quarter of 2024, U.S. credit card debt reached a whopping $1.14 trillion, a 5.8% increase from the previous year. Therefore, most citizens face the challenge of paying off collections. A paid collection may not necessarily affect your credit score, but there are various advantages to paying off a collection account. 

Here are some benefits of paying off unpaid creditors: It effectively averts a lawsuit from the original creditor or a debt collection agency. 

  • You can also prevent wage garnishments.  
  • You may find it easier to acquire new lines of credit. 
  • Your interest charges, along with other miscellaneous fees in your unpaid balances, can be reduced. 

A paid-off collection might not affect your credit score. However, it can provide you with the peace of mind that comes from no longer having to deal with debts in the future. 

Conclusion

While dealing with overwhelming collection accounts can be difficult, managing your payments and creating an optimal budget is achievable. By taking proactive steps with repayment plans and gaining a better understanding of changing credit scoring models, you can have greater control over your credit report. However, it’s advisable to consult experts when facing such dire situations. 

If you are seeking expert guidance on paying off your collections, Shepherd Outsourcing Services can provide tailored solutions that can help you resolve financial issues. Contact us to gain an upper hand on your collection accounts for long-term economic stability. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How much will my credit score increase if I pay a collection?

Paying off a collection debt might not necessarily improve your credit score. A collection account stays on your credit report for seven years, and after that period, it will be removed from your report. 

2. Can I improve my credit score with collections?

Paying off collections can help improve your credit score in some cases. However, settling a collection account only slightly improves your credit scores. 

3. Can I negotiate with debt collectors to have the collection removed after payment?

Yes, a pay-for-delete agreement allows your debt collection agency to remove your credit account upon complete payment. However, not all debt collectors agree to this, but it can be a solution to improve your credit report if successful.

 4. Do medical debts impact credit scores?

Under the FICO 9, 10, and VantageScore credit scoring models, medical loans have little impact on credit scores. Additionally, credit bureaus are eliminating small, paid medical collections from credit reports entirely. 

5. Should you pay off debts or seek settlements?

Paying your debts in full provides both legal and financial peace of mind. However, debt settlements may be recorded as “settled” on your credit report. New credit scoring models treat both options equally, while older models prefer a “fully paid” status.